The Era of Private Equity: Understanding the Denominator Effect
In the dynamic world of private equity, the year 2021 witnessed outstanding performance, leading to a significant decoupling of valuations in private markets from those of public equities and bonds in 2022. This shift resulted in a situation where many institutional investors found themselves over-allocated to private markets.
This phenomenon, known as the denominator effect, occurs when private asset allocations exceed a set threshold in an allocation policy. This creates the need for correction, particularly during a negative cash flow cycle when anticipated liquidity is reduced, and paper portfolio losses in traditional assets are already squeezing portfolios.
Despite some relief from the rebound in equity prices and a pause in interest rate hikes, the liquidity challenge in private markets persists, reinforcing the implications of the denominator effect. The need for liquidity has driven a rise in limited partner (LP)-led secondary sales in 2023, as revealed in recent Lazard research.
The Current PE Denominator Effect
The unprecedented divergence in relative performance and valuations between private markets and their public counterparts in 2022 initiated what may be termed as the real “outlier” year. While some relief was seen in 2023, the denominator effect was not fully offset by this reversal.
According to Cliffwater research, private equity showed superior returns of 54% in 2021 and 21% in 2022, outperforming public equities by significant margins. However, in 2023, private equity delivered only 0.8% returns compared to 17.5% from equities.
Impact of the Denominator Effect
The denominator effect affects investors differently based on their allocation status. For those still building their PE allocation, the effect can accelerate optimal portfolio construction. However, for those already near their target allocation with an overcommitted strategy, consequences include reduced allocations to current and future vintages, compromised risk diversification, and the crystallization of losses.
Tackling the Denominator Effect
To address the denominator effect, investors employ various strategies such as waiting, secondary sales, or more complex solutions like collateralized fund obligations (CFOs). While the wait-and-see strategy involves wider allocation bands and reduced commitments, CFOs provide a sophisticated tool to counter the effect.
Redefining Portfolio Management: Transferring PE Risk
Innovative research has paved the way for reshaping portfolio asset allocation through the trading of private fund yields. This approach transforms PE portfolios into yield curves to communicate returns effectively in a multi-asset, multi-period context.
By engaging in risk transfer transactions based on private fund yields, investors can enhance their portfolio management efficiency, manage market risk, and plan future liquidity needs. The introduction of technology and innovation in this process provides a more efficient toolkit for navigating the challenges posed by the denominator effect.
Conclusions
As macroeconomic scenarios evolve with potential interest rate hikes and prolonged negative cash flow cycles, investors must adapt and act swiftly to address the denominator effect. Leveraging technology and innovative strategies can help investors optimize their portfolios in the face of uncertainty and changing market dynamics.
If you found this post insightful, remember to subscribe to Enterprising Investor and the CFA Institute Research and Policy Center for more valuable insights.